Index for A Place to Browse - The Food Insects Newsletter Home
|
Michael Burgett The following preparation of honey bee brood, based on a recipe from Nepal, is the insect dish with which I have had the greatest success in consumer acceptance (consumers being identified for the most part as the undergraduate and graduate students in two courses I teach that include entomophagy as an important, albeit small aspect of both classes). The recipe was given to me in 1986 by Benjamin Underwood, at that time an entomology graduate student at the Dyce Laboratory of Honey Bee Biology, Cornell University, who was just completing a MS degree concerned with the natural history of the giant honey bee of the Himalayan foothills, Apis laboriosa Smith. The Nepalese term for the preparation is bakuti, and (in Nepal) it requires late-instar larvae, prepupae and pupae of the high altitude giant honey bee Apis laboriosa. (For a pictorially dramatic account of the plundering of these cliff nesting colonies see National Geographic, Nov. 1985, "Honey Hunters of Nepal", Valli & Summers.) The Nepalese preparation was of interest to me as I had several times witnessed and experienced giant honey bee brood (Apis
dorsata F.
as opposed to A. laboriosa) as a culinary item in northern Thailand where brood in the comb is wrapped in banana leaf and steamed. While tasty, it is not particularly stimulating from a visual sense, and the presence of wax required a fair amount of chewing (and spitting).
Bakuti is based on the extraction of the water soluble protein and liquid fats from whole larvae and
|
Sections of brood comb are placed in a woven, fabric bag and hand squeezed over an open container that collects the liquid phase. This liquid fraction is then heated and gently
stirred which, after about 5 minutes, results in a product that closely resembles, in color and texture, soft scrambled eggs. The odor and flavor qualities of bakuti are difficult to assess or to associate with foods familiar to North American/European palates. From a very subjective personal
perspective, I believe Ewell Gibbons would describe it as 'nut like.' It is my understanding that the Nepalese will add various available
animal and vegetable materials to it.
As giant honey bees are not indigenous to North America, and as Ben Underwood so quickly realized, we can easily substitute brood from our familiar European honey bee, Apis mellifera L. Honey bee brood is readily available (especially for university apiculturists) during the active foraging season. I have found that brood in virgin comb is more easily extracted than that coming from older, darker combs. For the non-beekeepers interested in experimenting with bakuti, take the time to discover a local beekeeper who would be willing to sell a few frames of brood (the secondary benefit here is that you won't have to face the venomous defense put forth during the removal of brood combs from a colony). Whole brood combs are easily stored by freezing until ready for use. My thanks to Ben Underwood for first turning me on to the flavorful experience of well prepared honey bee brood. |
|
The Insect Horror Film Festival which unfolded at Iowa State University on September 6-8 had more to offer than bug horror movies. A horror movie was indeed shown,as advertised, at 8:00 pm each evening. But the doors opened at 7:30 pm and those who were attracted by the prospect of seeing bug violence found that they had inadvertently exposed themselves to some additional education about insects. The Festival was sponsored by the Entomology Club, the Student Union Board and the ISU Committee on Lectures. |
Among the recipes featured at the Insect Tasting Event: Chocolate Covered Crickets: 2 squares of semi-sweet chocolate and 25 dry roasted crickets and/or grasshoppers with legs and wings plucked. Melt chocolate as directed on the box. Dip insects in chocolate, place on wax paper and refrigerate until party. Insect preparation: To clean insects, place in a collander or fine mesh strainer, rinse and pat dry. Dry roast in a
200°
oven, until crispy. They can then be ground into flour, cut into pieces or used whole.
The entomology students serving the insects attempted to make them irresistible by displaying them on silver trays with white tablecloths and candlelight. Cynthia Lidtke, an entomology student helping with the festival, said she hopes moviegoers will come away a little more appreciative of insects. "I hope they won't just step on them any more, and say, "Well, there's another one."
|
|
EDITOR'S CORNER |
issues correspondence generated by the Newsletter and other matters pertaining to insects as food. With the steadily increasing volume of such correspondence it is understandable that the Department has been hinting recently that this cannot go on forever. |
|
When Chicago Braced for the Onslaught of the 17-year Cicada Everyone agreed (well, almost everyone) one option was to eat them!!About the middle of May, the editor was interviewed at length (four times) by feature writer Larry Weintraub of the Chicago Sun-Times for a lengthy article called "Food for Thought" which was to appear in the Sunday, May 27th edition of the Sun-Times. The article was about the use of insects as food around the world, and it was to serve as sort of a centerpiece for two shorter articles by Weintraub. It soon became apparent that all of this was part of a massive effort to prepare Chicagoans for the impending appearance of the 17-year cicada. One of Weintraub's articles provided information on the life-cycle of the cicada and announced the existence of the CICADA HOTLINE which would be logging calls 24 hours a day. The second article began: "Millions of tasty, entrees-if-you-dare will be available for the gathering during the next month in northern Illinois, and some Chicagoans will want to know how cicada fanciers prepare them." It provided some recipes (see insert). The article recalled that Peter Kranz, a paleontologist and Washington, D.C., schoolteacher, served cicadas to hundreds of his students in the nation's capital three years ago when the noisy insects emerged there. "Most kids say they taste like french fries, popcorn and chicken," reported Kranz, who covered sauteed cicadas with cinnamon for breakfast and garlic and butter for snacks. Weintraub also quoted University of Chicago ecology professor Monte Lloyd that raw cicadas are of excellent flavor, tasting like raw potatoes sprinkled with avocado or clam.A few pages away in the Sun-Times was another article entitled, "Spray's no way to greet cicadas," by Scott Fomek. Fomek had marshalled a bevy of experts, mostly entomologists from the Field Museum and the University of Illinois Cooperative Extension, whose advice, in summary, was relax and don't spray. "As soon as you mention spraying, people will be out there with flame throwers and bazookas," said Daniel Summers at the Field Museum, who added that people who spray are bigger pests than the noisy cicadas. Since so many other animals--bi rds, racoons, and even people--eat cicadas, spraying contaminates a food source, Summers said. Adverse effects on beneficial insects were also mentioned.Recognizing that egg-laying, in which incisions are made in twigs, can do damage to young deciduous trees, the Chicago experts nevertheless played it cool. "Frankly, we at the Botanic Garden don't think it is anything to worry about," said Meegan McCarthy-Bilow, horticulturist at the Chicago Botanic Garden. "For the larger trees it's been described as just a natural pruning," said John Wagner, Field museum biologist "Just sit back and enjoy one of the most spectacular events the animal kingdom has to offer," said Phil Parrillo, a Field Museum entomologist. The consensus advice was that if you have a particularly valuable young tree, with trunk less than 1 1/2 inches across, wrap the top with cheese cloth or some other |
gauzelike fabric that lets in air and light (don't use plastic) and
tie it below the first branches. This will prevent egg-laying.
Apparently, however, not everybody in Chicagoland was as cool and reasoned as the writers and experts we've cited above. The May
30th Wisconsin State Journal (Madison newspaper) front-paged a story, date-lined Chicago: "This city is going bonkers over bugs. There are nightly updates on the TV news, recipes in the newspaper, even a special hotline heralding not the coming of the apocalypse, but the emergence of inch-long critters called cicadas .... The noisy devils unearth themselves every 17 years to mate, shriek incessantly,
and drive homeowners crazy
The cicadas have reached Elmhurst', a broadcaster announced in a teaser for a recent television newscast .... The orgy should be over by early July, and experts say the creatures are harmless. But that hasn't calmed the hysteria." By now, one of the resident Chicago experts cited above was showing signs of exasperation. "It's completely unfounded," said entomologist
Parrillo. "People are going out and getting insecticide to spray on them, but they're only going to be here for a few weeks. Gee whiz, don't worry about it." Parrillo was blaming the news media for helping create "cicada mania." SEE CICADAS, p. 5 |
|
Letters |
Abdomens tasted a bit like pungent aromatic curry spices with the added benefit of being slightly bitter and hydrolytic. Drones were great. Worker abdomens minus the sting apparatus were more or less ok, but did have a slightly noisome texture. Whole workers have the combined flavors mentioned above and would hardly be classified as savory. |
|
I've been fascinated with social insects since my early childhood. I have watched ants in their natural habitat and constructed artificial nests to observe them in the fall and winter. This experience was influential in my future career choices. I received a Ph.D. in entomology from the University of Wisconsin in 1989 and will soon be moving to Louisiana State University to be their resident urban entomologist. Dr. DeFoliart asked if I would relate some of my knowledge on collecting ant pupae for the readers of this newsletter. |
quickly reveal when the pupae can be harvested from all the mounds. Ant workers take meticulous care of their young. The smallest larvae are kept in moist areas of the mound. The pupae however need dry and warm conditions and are kept separate from the rest of the brood. The mound-builders make it particularly easy for pupae collection because the workers move them to the highest reaches of the mound where the sun can warm them. Formica adults will even remove the paper-like cocoon from the pupae several weeks before they have
sclerotized, sort of like shelling peanuts.
Gregg Henderson |
|
Recent Technical Papers
The authors suggest that the observed behavior is innate as the . experimental ducks had apparently had no previous experience with flies, yet fed on them readily even when provided feed ad lib. One of the ducks penned with a calf was observed to capture, on average, a mean of 23 flies per 32.5 attempts. Two (among several) advantages of the ducks were effectiveness against insecticide resistant flies and elimination of breeding sites by removing spilled feed. The ducks were also more economical than the commercial control devices. The authors estimate that under their local conditions a producer could make a profit of $65 on 10 ducks by selling them at the end of the season, while the other control |
devices range in cost from $171 to $455 for season-long fly removal. At a midsize dairy farm that kept unrestrained Muscovy ducks for fly control, the ducks stayed in the vicinity of the barn and interacted well with animals and humans. In addition to feeding on adult house flies, they also picked flies from the lower legs of cows, indicating that they were also feeding, on stable flies, Stomoxys
calcitrans
s
(L.). It should be noted that ducks cannot be used in commercial poultry operations because of disease hazards.
The plethora of recipes that appeared indicates that, for some reason, Americans consider cicadas, unlike most insects, as almost respectable food. Maybe, some day, a predicted periodical cicada emergence will automatically call for a community festival. The cicadas would provide not only the food, but also the music. The 1990 emergence extended (but barely) into southern Wisconsin, and one of our students, John Snell, harvested part of the crop at Lake Geneva. Roasted, the flavor was "meaty" and delicious. Surprisingly, with the tenerals (newly emerged from the soil) it really did prove to be unnecessary to remove the wings and legs. The next issue of the Newsletter will contain a short article on the identity, distribution, and predictability of cicada emergences in North America. |
|
Publication Announcement |
5. Social Wasps Among the Bribri of Costa Rica by Christopher K. Starr (Department of Horticulture, University of Georgia, Athens, GA, USA) and Maria Eugenia Bozzoli de Wille (Universidad de Costa Rica, San Jose, Costa Rica) 6. Insect Resources and Plio-Pleistocene Hominid Evolution by Mark Q Sutton (Department of Sociology and Anthropology, California State University, 9001 Stockdale Highway, Bakersfield, CA, USA) |
|
In almost every culture on the planet, insects are regarded as a delicious part of the diet. Not only do they provide essential nutrition to humans foraging in marginal environments, but certain species are sought-after gourmet items that demand top dollar in Oriental markets and upper-crust Mexico City restaurants. Among the few exceptions to this wide-spread entomophagy (eating of insects) are the European-derived cultures, which are increasingly imposing their misplaced squeamishness upon indigenous peoples - and malnutrition is the unfortunate result. As one Mexican agronomist observed, "More Mexicans would be eating bugs were it not for decades of ad campaigns by international companies pushing white bread and Spam." |
advocate the use of insects as food for both humans and livestock. Doesn't it make more sense, for example, to eat locusts (as generations of Africans and Native Americans have done) than to dump tons of pesticides on them? (And from all reports, they are quite tasty, similar to fried shrimp.) In fact, pound for pound, insect pests are often more nutritious
than
the crops they eat!
Ted Schultz |
|
Tentative Venture into Buying, Selling, Exchanging The editor teaches a
1
-credit course here at the University of Wisconsin on the human use of insects as food/animal feed, and the course is spiced-up considerably by having available (thanks to the generosity of a number of people in Africa, Asia and Mexico) some good examples in the form of dried or alcohol-preserved specimens, color slides and prints. Although the variety of samples accumulated so far is small compared to the great variety of species consumed, these visual aids elicit great interest from students.
It seems that the newsletter might perform a valuable service by offering to serve as a means of contact for those wishing to buy, sell or exchange materials that would be useful as teaching aids. Needless to say, 99% of the pertinent species (and especially the appropriate life stages) are not yet stocked by the biological supply houses, so there is no commercial source. For those of you who might wish to advertise your needs or offers in the Newsletter, remember that space is at a premium. So please keep them brief. |
**How to read your address label ** |